Karen & Ellen All articles
Friendship

She Made a Friend at Book Club and I spiraled for a Week: Notes From the Other Woman (It Was Me)

Karen & Ellen
She Made a Friend at Book Club and I spiraled for a Week: Notes From the Other Woman (It Was Me)

Photo: William H. Johnson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Text That Ruined My Tuesday

It was a completely normal Tuesday when Ellen texted me: "Met the coolest woman at book club. We talked for two hours. Getting brunch Saturday!"

Two hours. Brunch. Saturday.

I replied "OMG so fun!!" with the enthusiasm of a hostage. Then I sat in my kitchen and did something I'm not proud of: I checked her Instagram story three times and ate shredded cheese over the sink like a woman in a commercial for divorce lawyers.

Thirty-one years of friendship, one microphone, a shared group chat with its own vocabulary — and one brunch invitation had me spiraling.

Let Me Be Clear: I Am Not a Jealous Person

I want to state for the record that I am a secure, well-adjusted adult with a full life, a thriving career, and a skin care routine that costs more than my first car.

I am also, apparently, a person who can be undone by the phrase "getting brunch Saturday."

Here's the thing nobody tells you about old friendships: the longer they go, the more they become part of your identity. Ellen isn't just my friend. She's the person who knows why I don't eat at Olive Garden anymore. She's half of every inside joke I have. When someone new enters the picture, it doesn't feel like addition. It feels like a renovation — and nobody asked me if I approved the permits.

The Week of Subtle Sabotage (A Retrospective)

Did I mention, unprompted, that I'd read the book club's current pick "if anyone wanted a second opinion"? Yes.

Did I schedule a podcast recording "accidentally" during what I guessed was brunch o'clock? I cannot legally answer that.

Did I deliver a monologue about how "some people collect new friends like tote bags" to my husband, who responded by slowly leaving the room? Absolutely.

By day five, I had constructed an entire narrative in which I was the quaint childhood friend — beloved, sure, but destined for the friendship equivalent of the county fair ribbon. Participation tier. Honorable mention.

Then Ellen Said the Thing

Saturday night, after the legendary brunch, Ellen called me.

"Okay, so," she said, "I told Dana all about you. Like, an embarrassing amount about you. She said, and I quote, 'I feel like I already know her.'"

And then she laughed and said, "You know you're still my person, right? You got weird about it. I could tell."

I had been caught. But more importantly, I had been seen — which is, inconveniently, the entire foundation of our friendship.

What I Learned From My Own Bad Behavior

Once I stopped being embarrassed (I did not stop being embarrassed), I sat with the feeling, and here's what I figured out:

Jealousy in old friendships is usually fear wearing a costume. I wasn't afraid Ellen would like Dana more than me. I was afraid the version of herself she gets to be with a new person — unburdened by thirty years of context, free to reinvent — was a better version. That's not about Dana. That's about me.

New friends don't dilute old ones. They prove you're worth knowing. Ellen being someone Dana wants to grab brunch with is the same quality that made her grab coffee with me in 1994. Her likability isn't a limited resource I'm competing for.

Saying the quiet thing out loud fixes 90% of it. When I finally told Ellen I'd felt wobbly, she didn't mock me. Okay, she mocked me a little. But then she said, "You're the only person who's been there for every version of me. Dana's meeting the 2024 model. You own the whole catalog."

I cried. Then I made her repeat it so I could write it down. Which she knew I would.

How to Make Room Without Tearing the House Down

If your bestie has a new friend and your stomach is doing gymnastics, here's the playbook we've landed on:

1. Name the feeling to yourself first. You can't fix what you won't admit. Journal it, whisper it to your dog, whatever — just get honest before you get vocal.

2. Don't make the new friend a villain. Dana has done nothing wrong except be delightful. If you treat every new person as a threat, you'll eventually become the reason people don't introduce you to anyone.

3. Say the insecure thing with humor and honesty. "I got weird about brunch and I'm owning it" lands better than three weeks of passive-aggressive scheduling.

4. Add a chair, don't build a new table. The best outcome here isn't Ellen choosing. It's all three of us at a restaurant where Dana laughs at our jokes and Ellen points at me and says, "See? Told you."

5. Remember why you're scared. Usually it means the friendship matters enormously. That's not a flaw. That's the whole point.

The Third Chair

We had Dana over for podcast night last month. She was funny, she was kind, and she asked Ellen a question about her childhood that I've never thought to ask because I was there.

It turns out a thirty-one-year friendship has room in it. Not because it was underfilled — because it was built well. Good friendships are load-bearing. They can hold more than you think.

Ellen is still my person. Dana might become a person, too. And I'm learning that the heart, unlike my kitchen counter during a crisis, is not a limited surface area.

The cheese, however, was a low point. We don't need to discuss the cheese.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Check Landed and the Table Went Quiet: Our Three Rules for Money Between Friends

The Check Landed and the Table Went Quiet: Our Three Rules for Money Between Friends

The Checkbox Was Easy. The Phone Call Was Not.

The Checkbox Was Easy. The Phone Call Was Not.

The Fix-It Fast: What Thirty Days of No Unsolicited Advice Did to Our Friendship

The Fix-It Fast: What Thirty Days of No Unsolicited Advice Did to Our Friendship